Joe Caraco

← All umpires (2026)

5
Games
825
Called Pitches
88.12%
Accuracy
51.28%
Consistency (156 shadow-zone)
-2.40
Favor (Home, runs)

Consistency is accuracy on "shadow zone" pitches only — the genuinely borderline calls near the edge of the zone. Favor is the net run-value impact (site's own pitch-level run-expectancy model) of this umpire's missed calls toward home teams across their games this season; positive favors the home team, negative favors visitors.

Accuracy trend (2026-06-14 – 2026-07-22)
92.31% 85.31%
Season Miss-Rate Heatmap

Miss rate by pitch location across every game this umpire worked in 2026, normalized to each batter's own strike zone (0 = bottom of their zone, 1 = top).

0/39 missed (0%) 9/21 missed (43%) 0/28 missed (0%) 0/13 missed (0%) 3/14 missed (21%) 0/13 missed (0%) 4/21 missed (19%) 3/17 missed (18%) 1/21 missed (5%) 7/18 missed (39%) 2/14 missed (14%) 0/5 missed (0%) 1/17 missed (6%) 0/4 missed (0%) 0/14 missed (0%) 0/8 missed (0%) 0/12 missed (0%) 5/23 missed (22%) 0/3 missed (0%) 0/8 missed (0%) 0/17 missed (0%) 4/14 missed (29%) 0/8 missed (0%) 0/6 missed (0%) 4/12 missed (33%) 0/21 missed (0%) 2/13 missed (15%) 0/5 missed (0%) 0/21 missed (0%) 7/16 missed (44%) 0/27 missed (0%) 0/15 missed (0%) 1/15 missed (7%) 0/13 missed (0%) 0/7 missed (0%) 0/9 missed (0%) 0/7 missed (0%) 3/18 missed (17%) 2/11 missed (18%) 3/16 missed (19%) 0/10 missed (0%) 0/6 missed (0%) 0/3 missed (0%) 0/17 missed (0%) 0/8 missed (0%) 4/17 missed (24%) 6/21 missed (29%) 5/17 missed (29%) 0/14 missed (0%) 1/17 missed (6%) 8/18 missed (44%) 3/23 missed (13%) 3/7 missed (43%) 1/8 missed (12%) 0/2 missed (0%) 6/23 missed (26%) 0/3 missed (0%) 0/9 missed (0%) 0/3 missed (0%) 0/5 missed (0%) 0/8 missed (0%)
Miss rate: 0% 100%
Game Log
Date Matchup Called Pitches Correct Accuracy% Missed Strikes Missed Balls Graced Consistency% Favor (Home) Zone Chart
2026-06-14 Harwich Mariners @ Bourne Braves 177 151 85.31% 2 24 10 46.88% -0.79 View →
2026-06-19 Cotuit Kettleers @ Yarmouth-Dennis Red Sox 144 126 87.5% 0 18 7 44.44% -0.91 View →
2026-06-27 Cotuit Kettleers @ Brewster Whitecaps 163 145 88.96% 1 17 5 41.67% -0.91 View →
2026-07-08 Yarmouth-Dennis Red Sox @ Wareham Gatemen 159 137 86.16% 1 21 10 53.66% -0.08 View →
2026-07-22 Brewster Whitecaps @ Wareham Gatemen 182 168 92.31% 0 14 7 65.62% +0.29 View →